• PORTFOLIOS
  • Prints
  • Licensing
  • Books
  • About
  • CONTACT
  • Blog
  • Instagram
  • LINKS
  • TECH INFO
Menu

William Karl Valentine

  • PORTFOLIOS
  • Prints
  • Licensing
  • Books
  • About
  • CONTACT
  • Blog
  • Instagram
  • LINKS
  • TECH INFO

Photographing the Doo Dah Parade in Pasadena with Frank on 11-24-24

Frank Schlegel (who lost his home) and other photographers of the Eaton Fire

March 5, 2025

I have known Frank Schlegel for well over forty years and first met him when he was working for Mike O’Brien who owned Flag’s Photo in Pasadena. When Flag’s closed Frank went to work for Samys Camera and he has been one of my best photography equipment contacts throughout my entire career. Frank and I have photographed together, most recently the last Doo Dah Parade in Pasadena, and he did my portrait for the dust cover of my Santa Anita book. Pasadena has a wonderful history of photography. The Huntington Library has an amazing photography collection, Pasadena City College and the Art Center of Design have good photography programs and going back to Adam Clark Vroman there have been some decent photographers who have called Pasadena home. Pasadena is one of those places if you grew up there you are always connected to the city whether or not you still live there or you move away. Frank has been a fixture in the Pasadena photo community for as long as I can remember. On January 7th, Frank lost his apartment, and most of his belongings, in the Eaton Fire. His apartment was four and a half blocks away from my mom’s house/

A number of Frank’s friends have stepped up to help him and I have tried to make myself available whenever he wanted to talk. The first couple conversations he really was dealing with the loss, there obviously was some shock still, but he was positive when it came to the task of moving forward. Shortly after the fire had swept through his neighborhood Frank started to photograph the devastation and his images were good, some of his best. I think Frank’s unique perspective was the reason. We talked about his photographs, and it was amazing how Frank was able to use his camera in healing process.

I think many of Frank’s Eaton Fire images are different from of my photographs in that he has really been locating and documenting incredible small details within the devastation. His photographic style or interest often was that way, for instance he loves photographing plant details at the Huntington Library, but the fire damage images are deeper because of his experience. I know my photographs from the Eaton Fire are different, my approach is different, I am photographing in a more methodical approach, almost forensic at times, spending more time in places. Every time I am up there photographing still has an intensity and with some emotional drain. I might be biased but there just seems to be a slight difference with photographs by local photographers who knew the area and ones who have come in from the outside. I know Pulitzer Prize winning photographer Nick Ut lives in Orange County and did an amazing job going from the Palisades Fire to the Eaton Fire in the first 24 hours. Nick is incredible with how much he is able to photograph, especially considering he is retired. Nick did a good job documenting a lot of different things in Altadena, especially the firefight, but he’s a press photographer it’s a different approach. I know Ken Light came down from the Bay Area and photographed both the Palisades and Altadena, but I have only seen a couple photographs from both locations, so I don’t know what his portfolio looks like. He is a good documentary photographer so I am interested to see what he photographed. Anther photographer that has stood out to me with the Eaton Fire is retired Pasadena Star News Photographer Walt Mancini, who was an outstanding local press photographer. I don’t think Walt was out photographing during the height of the fires, which was smart, but he was out the next day and has documented so many important things. The key to his images is he knows that area better than anyone else, and it shows in his images. As a kid and young photographer, I took note of Walt’s photographs in the paper all the time, and I know his images had an impact on my development as a photographer.

I have been trying to get Frank to write something for this blog post, but I know he has been too busy out photographing whenever he wasn’t working so I am still waiting on that. I even stopped by and saw him at Samy’s yesterday and checked in on him, he is doing good. When I get some writings, I will update this post with his words. While I was waiting for my camera sensors to be cleaned, I also talked with Jason Lyman, who manages the Pasadena Samys. Jason shared some interesting insight; he said sales were noticeably higher since the Eaton Fire. He said many customers were affected by the fires and he thought many of them were photographing the aftermath as part of the healing process. Below are screen grabs of some of Frank’s recent images as well as some of the other photographers Eaton Fire images.

UPDATE INFORMATION - On March 13th The Pasadena Weekly wrote an article about the Keychain Project and interviewed Frank. The Eaton Canyon Keychain Project is an art project where they collect keys to create works to memorial the loss of the Eaton Fire. Please check out the link.

Frank Schlegel’s Eaton Fire Portfolio:

View fullsize Frank's Apartment
View fullsize IMG_3998.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4066.jpg
View fullsize IMG_2404.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4394.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4393.jpg
View fullsize Day Care across the street from his apartment
View fullsize IMG_2405.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4374.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4392.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4372.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4366.jpg
View fullsize IMG_2403.PNG
View fullsize IMG_3506 (1).jpg
View fullsize IMG_4383.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4387.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4390.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4381.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4368.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4375.jpg
View fullsize Screenshot 2025-02-16 at 11.21.38 PM.jpeg
View fullsize IMG_4371.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4388.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4389.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4382.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4384.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4370.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4378.jpg
View fullsize IMG_2406.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4385.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4377.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4373.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4369.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4380.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4379.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4367.jpg
View fullsize IMG_4041.jpg
View fullsize IMG_2409.jpg
View fullsize IMG_2407.jpg

Some of Nick Ut’s photographs are below. I am still amazed that he photographed in the Palisades and was able to make it to the Altadena while the Eaton Fire was still burning. He does am amazing job going to the hard areas to photograph and I have come to really like his selfies to prove he was there.

View fullsize IMG_3539 (2).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3546 (2).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3541 (2).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3533 (1).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3542 (2).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3544 (2).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3538 (2).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3536 (1).jpg
View fullsize IMG_3537 (2).jpg

Kyle Grillot - Photographer

Kyle Grillot is a press photographer who captured one of the most iconic images from the Eaton Fire when he photographed Pasadena PD Officer Banuelos carrying a man to safety in Altadena (See Below), I believe on the morning of 1/8/25. I was not aware of Kyle’s work before seeing this image. He is a graduate of THE Ohio State University, and he has been photographing professionally for fifteen years. He absolutely is willing to go into the danger zone, his fire photographs, when he is in the middle of ember cast or raging flames are incredible. Among others, he photographs for the New York Times. I encourage you to follow him and check out his website. On his website check out the image of a Joshua Tree during the Bob Cat Fire, it is amazing. He was on Instagram @kylegrillot but minutes ago he made a post about Meta and said he was moving to Bluesky’s Flashes so hopefully you can track down his images.

Wally Skalij - Photographer

One last mention, I know Wally Skalij was out in the Palisades Fire, I am not sure if he made it to the Eaton Fire. Wally just announced his retirement from the staff of the Los Angelses Times yesterday. Wally was arguably the best Press Photographer of his era. He is a good documentary photographer, and I look forward to the portfolios he works on going forward now that he can be selective in his topics. He is another photographer who captured amazing images when he ran into the flames.

In Photography Tags Eaton Canyon, Eaton Fire, Frank Schlegel, Souther California Wildfires, Photography, Photographer, Wally Skalij, Kyle Grillot, Altadena, Altadena Strong, Samys camera
1 Comment

Don Norgood’s Photograph of Pasadena PD Motor Officer Tom Young on Green Street East of Orange Grove.

Appeared in Life Magazine on July 19th, 1969 - Originally published in the Pasadena Star News

LOWDOWN / SHOWDOWN Ed Norgood’s Photo of Pasadena PD Motor Officer Tom Young

January 19, 2025

Last November I was really focused on my hometown of Pasadena. I am up there a couple times a week to see my mom and check on things as it is but in November, I photographed the Doo Dah Parade again for the first time in a while and then the Pasadena Polic Department Alumni group on Facebook shared the above photograph which I remember really well from my childhood. I decided to research the image and write blog post about it. I at first thought long time Pasadena Star News Photographer Walt Mancini captured the image but after figuring out which issue of Life it appeared in, and actually purchasing a copy of it, I learned it was Ed Norgood’s photograph. Ed was another well-known Pasadena press photographer. I started writing this a month ago then all hell broke loose so I am just know trying to get caught up. As photographers I think there is value in looking at other photographer’s work. Most often that is involves examining images to understand the medium better, but in this case, I think seeing the life path that photography gave to Ed is also a valuable lesson.

Pasadena has been home to a number of good photographers, especially a number of good Press Photographers like John Lloyd, Walt Mancini, and Ed Norgood who captured the image above. For a press photographer I think Pasadena was ideal at the end of the last century because the Star News, the local paper, had great circulation, there were plenty of unique events to cover in Pasadena with the Rose Parade, Rose Bowl game, Super Bowls. Other prominent places like The Huntington Library, JPL, and Cal Tech are in Pasadena plus they got to cover events in Los Angeles because it was so close. It was the best of all worlds for a press photographer because you often had small town pace but then big-time action (and back then a paycheck). The pace allowed Ed Norgood the opportunity to see this image, photograph it, and get it published - eventually having it published in Life Magazine.

There have been other photographers come out of Pasadena like Adam Clark Vroman and myself (sorry I couldn’t resist) plus Pasadena City College had an outstanding photography program when I was there with people like Walt Girdner, “Uncle Walt”, who taught me my first photography class. I was lucky to be born and raised in the area.

The General

Often with a great image we lose sight of the people in them or at least their own story beyond the one image. Tom Young was a legendary officer at Pasadena, not only because he was a beast of a man but just because how well he controlled situations on the street. His nickname was the General and everyone loved working with him. The number of great comments about him on the Facebook post were amazing to read. I remember my dad showing me the photograph when I was a little kid and being proud that his friend, and someone from Pasadena PD, had been featured in Lide Magazine.

Interview by: Scott Swanson

Below is an interesting interview I found of Ed from the really small-town paper where he retired. I think it is an outstanding piece and gives insight in to why photographers photograph. The link is below, and I also copied and pasted the whole story because it had problems loading for me a couple of times.

The New Era - November 28, 2007

Edwin Norgord didn’t grow up intending to be a news photographer.

He actually intended to be an agricultural inspector in the citrus orchards of Southern California in the early 1950s.

But when that didn’t work out for him, he decided to take a photography class and ended up working for a Pasadena newspaper for 35 years, during which he shot movie stars, presidents, sports heroes and a lot of everyday human-interest photos, which were some of his favorites.

“The reason I love newspaper photography is because I dealt with people in all walks of life – the good, the ugly, the rich, the poor,” said Norgord, who will be 78 next month. “I’ve seen football players cry – just the emotion of people, trying to capture it on film.”

He did it well enough that he was recognized by his colleagues as the California Press Photographer of the Year in 1970.

Norgord was born and raised in Pasadena, Calif., about 10 miles northeast of Los Angeles, one of a family of seven children. He attended Marshall High School and John Muir Junior College during World War II before joining the Air Force in 1948 and serving in Japan during the Korean War.

After he was discharged in 1949, he enrolled in the Voorhis Unit of the California Polytechnic School in San Dimas, about 20 miles east of Pasadena. The college was all-male, so he and his buddies would cruise to other, all-female, campuses for social interaction.

“We had to go to the girls college in LaVerne (a few miles to the east) if we wanted to gallivant,” Norgord recalled. “When I got discharged, I bought a brand new car, a 1950 Chevy, and all the other college boys wanted to ride around in my car because it had skirts and pipes. That was my downfall because we were driving around to different girls schools and I wasn’t keeping up on my studies.”

Norgord said he also discovered that majoring in agriculture wasn’t for him.

“I couldn’t dissect leaves very well,” he said.

Transferring to Pasadena City College, he took a photography course and started chumming around with a friend, Elton Sewell, who was a photographer for the Pasadena Independent, a local tabloid newspaper.

“He got me started, really,” Norgord said. “He lent me a camera to use. I started to take pictures for the Independent – human interest, weather, accident photos.”

The editors liked his stuff and when an opening came up, they hired him to work weekends as a part-timer. He started working for the Independent full-time in 1954.

He said he particularly enjoyed working for Fred Runyon, the editor.

“He was the nicest guy you’d want to meet,” Norgord said. “A super, wonderful guy.

“One time when I was in the darkroom, I had taken a picture of my father-in-law taking a sliver out of his granddaughter’s hand. I walked into the house and saw him about ready to take the sliver out.

“I said ‘Hold it!’ and I ran out and got my Speedgraphic camera. They were under a desk lamp, so I took the bulb out and plugged a flashbulb into the lamp using this converter I had. Then I told them to go ahead and take sliver out. By the time I put the (film) slide back in, and got another negative in, he had the sliver out and the moment was past.

“I was in the darkroom printing this up, when my editor walked in and saw the print. I thought he was going to raise hell because I was doing this on company time. He said, ‘I’m going to fire you, Eddie, if you don’t enter this in a national contest.’ I did and got second place.

“He let reporters do whatever they wanted as long as they got job done.”

Norgord said he really enjoyed working with the reporters at the Independent, whom he said were “wonderful people.”

There was a lot of camaraderie and cooperation between public officials and the press, he said.

“In those days, if we all hung out in the press room at the police department, if there was a fire alarm, all of us photographers – from the L.A. Times, the Examiner, the Independent, the Herald Express, would jump in one car and follow the police car through red lights. They really worked with us in those days.

“Firefighters would urge us to go up the ladder to shoot a picture from the roof. They were very, very cooperative then.

“When one of the photographers was drunk, we’d shoot a holder for them.”

The job was enjoyable because it had challenge and he enjoyed working with people.

The whole idea of taking pictures is to try to illustrate a story, Norgord said, noting that the ability to spot situations with photo potential is key. One time, he said, he was supposed to shoot a photo to illustrate the start of spring.

“I went out and found a flower growing out of a spring sticking out of the ground in a vacant lot. You’re looking for things like that. It feels so great to go in and put a print like that on (the editor’s) desk.”

Norgord said he shot “lots of movie stars” including Bob Hope, Frank Sinatra and Gene Autry. He visited stars’ homes in Pasadena as well.

He also shot several presidents, but he particularly remembers one, Richard Nixon.

“I was really impressed by his brilliance, his speaking ability,” Norgord said. “He had an incredible memory. But I was jinxed by him.”

The first time he shot Nixon was at a hotel in Arcadia, near Pasadena. The president walked by, entering the hotel, and as Norgord was taking a photo, his Speedgraphic flash fell off and landed on Nixon’s foot.

Then, a few years later, he was at Nixon’s alma mater, Whittier College, about 15 miles south of Pasadena. Air had gotten into one of his flashbulbs, but as he reached into his bag to grab a bulb. he didn’t notice that the indicator dot on the bulb had turned pink, an indicator that the bulb was defective.

“I took a photo of him and Pat on the football field as he was giving a talk and my flash exploded and made a loud noise, flame shot out, and it sent glass all over him and Pat,” Norgord said. “I was so embarrassed by that. If it had been today, I would have been shot before I could explain.”

The last time Norgord photographed Nixon was at the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles. He and reporter Lou Spear went to Nixon’s room and after they were searched by a Secret Service agent, they entered the room where Nixon was sitting in a swivel chair.

“He swiveled around and looked at me and pointed his finger at me. ‘I know you, I know you,’ he said.

“I said, ‘Sir, do you want me to leave?’

“He said, ‘No, come on in.’

Norgord wanted to shoot the photo with available light but he had to avoid shooting a profile of Nixon’s nose, by the president’s request.

“He is one president who uses hand language. He speaks with his hands,” Norgord said. “I got some tremendous shots of him. When I went back, they were on deadline. They ran a one-column mug with no hands or anything. That upset me a little bit.”

One of his more exciting experiences was during a forest fire that he covered soon after starting with the Independent. He drove into the mountains north of Pasadena and found a camp full of firefighters who were sleeping after working on the fire line.

“I was taking pictures when the fire captain told me I had to leave because they were evacuating because the fire was coming toward them,” Norgord said.

As he left, he made a wrong turn on the dirt road and drove for miles on a road that was too narrow to turn the car around. Suddenly, embers started raining down on him and the car began overheating because the air temperature was about 115 degrees due to the advancing flames. Norgord was also almost out of gas.

Finally, he came upon a highway patrolman who was blocking the road.

“He said, ‘I thought the road was burned out back there,'” Norgord recalled. “I couldn’t talk because my throat was so dry.”

The police officer let him through and he made it to a nearby ranger station where he was able to beg a couple of gallons of gas. He also got a ride on a water tender to the fire.

“I ended up getting some of best fire photos of my career there,” he said. “They ran in our paper and in a magazine called ‘Stag.'”

The assignments he “dreaded” were “high-society” shots.

But, he said, even they sometimes turned out to be less than onerous.

“The people who had the money didn’t have to prove it,” Norgord said, relating a story of the time he was on an assignment in which he and a “society lady” drove up a long, brick driveway.

When they got to the mansion at the top, the woman went into the house and Norgord started talking with a man who was pruning roses nearby.

“When we left, the lady said, ‘Ed, do you know who that was?'”

Norgord said he assumed it was a gardener. Turns out, he said, it was the vice-president of Standard Oil.

Sometimes, he said, news photos didn’t come easily even when they were easy to get to.

That happened on June 6, 1968 after Robert F. Kennedy was shot by Sirhan Sirhan in the kitchen of the Ambassador Hotel. Sirhan’s mother worked at a local Roman Catholic church and Norgord went to try to get a photo of her.

“I went to the church where his mother worked and the priest asked me what I was doing there,” he remembered. “I said, ‘I’d like to take a picture of Mrs. Sirhan Sirhan if you haven’t told her yet.’

“He said, ‘We haven’t told her yet but we don’t want you to take a picture when she finds out. ‘

“I said, ‘I respect your wishes, but this is not local news, this isn’t even national news. This is an international story. I’d like to record this for history.’

“The priest said, ‘You know, you’re right.’ He said he’d let me take one picture when they told her.

“Sometimes you have to talk your way into news photos.”

Norgord worked at the Independent until the Knight-Ridder company bought the newspaper in 1988 and merged it with the Star-News. He was 58 and he decided to retire.

He and his wife moved to Mono Village, a resort outside Bridgeport in the eastern Sierras. He worked at the boat dock and in the grocery store and stopped taking photos for a while, he said.

“I loved my work while I was at the newspaper, but I had to get out,” he said, adding that his departure was hastened by a change in management.

After a divorce from his first wife, Norgord married a “long-time acquaintance” and they moved to Sweet Home in 1992.

“I loved the country, the outdoors and I wanted to get away from the big city,” he said.

His wife, Sherry, works for the Linn-Co Credit Union.

“She’s quite a bit younger than I,” Norgord said. “That’s what keeps me young.”

Now that he’s retired, he still has an interest in photography. He’s been drafted as the official photographer at the Evangelical Church and he’s still a member of the Los Angeles Press Photographer’s Association, so he enjoys seeing the work of photographers he knows who are still in the business.

The technology has changed drastically since he stopped taking news photos – news photographers have switched to digital and the darkrooms at most newspapers are obsolete.

“I have a digital camera now,” he said. “I’m still learning about it. Today I’m so blessed to have a self-focused, automatic camera now because my eyes are bad.

“Photography has gone a long way – It’s a lot easier to cope with than back in my day, especially with a Speedgraphic.

Photography was fun, mainly because of the people he worked with, he said.

“To me, it was a God-given great job that I had,” Norgord said. “I worked with wonderful people. Most people don’t have a job that they enjoy that much. I got an awful lot of prestige in my job. It was quite a reward to open up the paper and see your work in it. “

Photographer Ed Norgood (featured photograph for this blog post is visible behind him.

View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6215_ 11292024  _1.jpg
View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6217_ 11292024  .jpg

Technology today is in many ways wonderous. First I was able to be reminded about this image I remember from my childhood by a Facebook post on the Pasadena PD’s alumni group’s page that I am a member of. From there I was able to research the Life issue more, find multiple vendors across America selling copies, and I was able to order one in very good condition to add to my photography collection. Finally, from there I was able to search the web for more information the photographer Ed Norgood. I found a needle in the haystack by locating the above article from 17 years ago (almost to the day) by a small-town paper in Oregon where Ed had retired. Those are all the cool things. But the pace of today’s world has pretty much killed, or permanently changed, all the big print media like picture magazines and major newspapers. I grew up with the Pasadena Star News, it somehow still survives but it is a shell of what it once was. Multiple small papers have been condensed into it, so it covers a massive era in less depth and the staff is a fraction of what it once was. I touched on this with my Doo Dah Parade blog post that will follow this post. Old magazines and newspapers are amazing documents well beyond the individual story you are referencing back to today. these publications allow us to have a more complete picture of the moments in time they documented and that is something we are losing now with or instant gratification look and swipe world of digesting information. Another thing we are losing is in this era you knew your news source and over time you could develop a trust of, or a distrust, of your source because it was mostly consistent. Today we see so much information from so many different sources many of which we have no idea how reliable they are. It is truly a double edge sword that I fear will do more damage than good over time unless there are fresh ideas on how to improve how we vet today’s sources. This is going to get especially had soon because of all the AI content that is and will be generated in the coming days.

Below are six images from the same Life issue that I found interesting. 55 years ago they were reporting on Presidents and global warming which we are still talking about but look at the products being advertised! The country was aware of women’s rights but related it to cigarettes which now have limited advertising and less users. Every cellphone now produces better video quality that Kodak’s movie camera. Then finally we are now moving to electric and hybrid vehicles instead of this gas hog Continental Mark III (which is amazingly gorgeous beast).

View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6229_ 11292024  .jpg
View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6227_ 11292024  .jpg
View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6219_ 11292024  .jpg
View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6223_ 11292024  .jpg
View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6225_ 11292024  .jpg
View fullsize Web1 CA DSC_6231_ 11292024  .jpg
In Photographer Tags Ed Norgood, Pasadena Star News, Pasadena Police Department, Life, Life Magazine, Scott Swanson, The New Era, Photography, Press Photography, Photographer, Walt Mancini, Walt Girdner
Comment

George A. Tice - Photographer October 13, 1938 – January 16, 2025

January 19, 2025

I have a limited number of other photographer’s work in my collection, something I should probably be better about. One print I do have is the above George Tice print Ferry Slip, Jersey City, NJ 1979. I purchased it over 25 years ago, can’t remember the cost, it was reasonable because he produced large editions, but I added it because I loved the composition and tonality of the print plus I also like New York City a lot. The number one rule in buying any work of art is you have to enjoy it, its never solely about investing.

Sadly, George A. Tice passed away on January 16th at 86 and I just heard about it.

George A. Tice - Country Road Landcaster PA 1961 - One of his most well-known images.

Gallery Gadcollection has an excellent webpage dedicated to Tice including an embedded video interview of him from 2019 where interestingly the last of six questions they aske him is about when he meets God. The page details most of Tice’s highlights and nice because it is so clear and concise. I also loved the fact that Tice chose a print of Ferry Slip to be in the video right behind him which suggests that is one of his favorite images too. There is also an interesting image on this page that Tice captured in 1959 of an explosion on the USS Wasp while he was in the Navy. He was no more than 21 years old at the time and I find this image incredible because it immediately reminded me of the Steerage by Stieglitz.

Tice’s work is in numerous permanent collections and for me it is sad every time our medium loses another icon. I am thankful for the work he left us with.

In Photographer Tags George A. Tice, Documentary Photography, Photography, Photographer, obituary
Comment

CHI DSC 3029 3-22-24 “Untitled” (Wells & Wacher, Chicago)

Chicago Photograph brings back memories of 25 years ago

June 21, 2024

When I got back from Chicago in March and started going through all my images I came across this photograph above. At first glance I saw how the elements in the frame were interesting, and I understood how I was drawn to make the exposure. But when I zoomed in, I immediately realized that the little girl in the stroller looked so similar to my daughter Alyssa at that age and that reminded me how often we used to take her to Chicago for vacations. The little girl in the stroller is so alert to the world around her just like Alyssa was at that age. I am assuming it was seeing the stuffed animal in the girl’s arm that really made the connection. The girl is clutching it in such a protective way, you know how special the toy is for her. My daughter was exactly the same way, and that period of innocence was so wonderful. The image brought to mind how much a parent tries and protect their children when they are young and also how in today’s society I still worry about my adult children’s safety as crime and world tensions rise. Viewing this image became an incredibly intense experience rather quickly as I realized everything I just mentioned, and I was not expecting that. The experience motivated me to revisit my negatives and see what images I had of Alyssa when we would take her Chicago when she was young. Below is one of my Chicago photographs from 25 years ago when Alyssa two years old.

CHI-171 #29 5-03-99 - Alyssa Valentine at the Hancock Tower

I don’t know if there is too much more to say about these images or the recent experience. I don’t want to make it into something more than it is, but I thought there was value in sharing how I felt with people interested in my work or just interested a photographer’s process. I think it not only gives insight to the fact I am an admitted romantic, but it also highlights how a photograph can evoke strong emotions from the image maker even when that was not the original intent. I know everyone brings their own experiences with them when they view an image and that people often have different responses to images based on their own prior experiences. I also want to point out that images can become more important overtime and develop new layers of meaning particularly if public opinion of the subject matter changes or if the subject matter documents change in and of itself. Viewers opinions can also change over time as they have different experiences with the same image. These are all some of the reasons why I don’t delete image files or purge old negatives.

In Artist, Street Photography, Photographer, Photography Tags Looking at Photographs, Chicago, Street Photography, Power of Photography, Photography, Photographer, Daughters, Alyssa Valentine
Comment
View fullsize Attachment-1 (30).jpeg
View fullsize Attachment-1 (31).jpeg

Controversy over Garry Winogrand's Photograph of a couple at the Central Park Zoo

March 9, 2024

In authoring a blog post on the book Winogrand Color I came across a review of the book online by New York Times writer Arthur Lubow. I think it was a really accurate review about the images in the book. The only thing I didn’t agree with that Lubow wrote were part of his comments on the very famous Winogrand photograph on the left above. Lubow wrote “Even less successful is the color version of one of his most famous photographs, “Central Park Zoo, New York City” (1967), which shows a Black man and blonde woman, seemingly affluent, each carrying a fully clad chimpanzee. It is a biting and unsettling comment on the era’s prevailing slurs about interracial marriage. In the color image, probably taken an instant later, the man is looking at the camera, the woman’s expression has changed, and the impact is diffused by the photographer’s own obscuring shadow and a distracting crowd of passers-by.” As I stated in my other blog post I saw the Winogrand documentary film, “All Things are Photographable” where Papageorge discussed this image and shared his own photograph of Winogrand with the couple. Tod Papageorge explained he was with Garry Winogrand that day and he disputed the assumption that Winogrand was making a statement about interracial relationships with this photograph. Tod and Garry were close friends and I think Tod would have understanding of Garry’s beliefs and opinions. I researched this subject matter further and found an in-depth article, with photograph illustrations, that Papageorge had authored about the photograph for Transatlantica in 2014 on MoMA’s website.

I know I have shared this information in the body of another blog post, but I think the subject is important enough to highlight in a separate post specifically dealing with the perceived controversy with this image because it applies to other works by other people. It is wrong to apply current day feelings or cultural standards with things from the past. I am not saying we need to condone outdated beliefs or past behavior that would be wrong in our world today. I am saying things needs to be evaluated with perspective of the time of the event and without any attempt to cancel it because of the current values and opinions of a segment of society. Here is a good non-photo example of my point:

My son is a graduate of Choate Rosemary Hall, a well-known prep school in Connecticut. On one of my many visits back there I got to sit in on his English class during the events of a “parents’ weekend”. My son’s teacher was Ed McCatty who is an outstanding educator, now retired. McCatty, who is black, had the class reading Mark Twain’s 1884 classic book “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” at the time. In the classroom, with all these other parents visiting, McCatty called on a student to read the book out loud and the student became nervous because of the book uses the “N-word” a fair amount to describe Huck’s friend Jim who was a fugitive slave. Finally, McCatty took over reading and projected Twain’s words eloquently. Parents squirmed uncomfortably as McCatty read “that word” again and again. I had already met Ed on a previous visit, he was one of the faculty residents in my son’s dorm, I knew where he was going with the reading, so I sat back and enjoyed seeing a number of parents getting completely stressed over words written in the 19th century. McCatty eventually explained how it was important to interpret Twain’s writing based on the time it was written. He pointed out that even though Huck was using the term for Jim that it wasn’t being used in a derogatory manner for the time, and the fact that Twain wrote about a young white youth befriending a black fugitive slave it showed Twain had a progressive viewpoint. McCatty took the topic further, using examples in his own life, and ended up giving everyone a lesson that day which went far beyond literature.

Interpretations of images (and other things) can change quickly, we don’t need a hundred plus years to pass for feelings to change. The best example of this with my own work is this photograph below which is in the permanent collection at the Center for Creative Photography.

PPD-177 #23 March 1987 - William Karl Valentine

Officer Ware and Craddolph at search warrant related to a narcotics sales investigation.

When I displayed this photograph in the first couple decades after making the exposure most every viewer was compassionate for the child being raised in dangerous conditions and anger towards the parents for putting the child in the situation. Some people went on to acknowledge gratefulness for law enforcement for trying to protect the child and do something about the drug epidemic of the times. These are accurate opinions about what my image is about. But in the last decade plus a portion of our society has altered its perspective on law enforcement and I have been confronted about this image. I had an anonymous Instagram viewer question my ethics for taking the photograph when the woman was unable to defend herself. In 2020 the photograph was in a simple exhibition in Pasadena and several people demanded to have it taken down because they found it offensive, so that image was pulled from the wall by staff. I am fine with someone not liking my work or disagreeing with my interpretation of the world, but to censor me is outlandish. The First Amendment gives me as much right to express myself opinion as anyone else in this country. The fact that some people thing their feeling give them the authority to remove that right is infuriating. Most photographs are an accurate account of a fraction of a second of time, how we interpret them is another thing.

One final thing I want to get back to, the majority of Arthur Lubow’s opinion on Winogran’s color photograph of the couple at the Central Park Zoo is spot on. The image is not as good as the famous black and white image and for all the reasons Lubow points out in his description of the image. Lubow obviously knows how to look at photographs. The positioning of the subjects in the frame and Winogrand’s shadow make the color image way less impactful. If Winogrand had been using a digital camera, which obviously did not exist then, and decided to share this famous image in color I think it may have been impactful, but I can see how the bright colors could have been distracting from what was going on in the frame. I know in my own work sometimes bright colors in a color image distract the viewer from the shapes, forms, layers of meaning, and textures in the image which drew my eye. That was a big consideration I had with my Santa Anita book, I didn’t want the viewer to focus on the bright colors of the silks, the horses, and the grass, I wanted them to see the details and layers of information that came out in a black and white image. It is natural that our eyes are drawn to bright colors and when color is removed a photographer can direct the focus in an image. There are times that colors matter and for that I am thankful for the digital age where the decision can be made after the shutter was released. Knowing how many rolls of film that Winogrand exposed I can only imagine how many hard drives he would have filled and the thousands of more images he would have made.

In Photographer, Photography, Street Photography Tags Ed McCatty, Choate, Choate Rosemary Hall, Garry Winogrand, Tod Papageorge, Documentary Photography, Photographer, William Karl Valentine, Pasadena Police Department, censorship, The Center for Creative Photography
1 Comment

BLM Protest - Newport Beach, California (NB DSC 6686 6-06-20)

Picturing Resistance Exhibition at Art Intersection Gallery - Gilbert, Arizona

July 13, 2023

I am proud to announce that legendary photojournalist, and educator, Ken Light has selected three of my photographs for inclusion in the Picturing Resistance Exhibition at Art Intersection Gallery in Gilbert, Arizona. The exhibition runs August 12th through September 30th and includes 59 photographs.

Protest against Governor Newsom’s orders to close the beaches during the Covid Pandemic - Huntington Beach, California (HB DSC 9916 5-01-20)

BLM Protest - Hollywood, California (CA DSC 5652 6-02-20)

I have enjoyed Ken Light’s work for some time, and his books “Texas Death Row” and “Course of the Empire” are in my library. Ken is a great photographer to follow on social media. Not only has he been documenting America, and other parts of the world, for 50 years, but he is also the Reva and David Logan Professor of Photojournalism and curator of the Center for Photography at the Graduate School of Journalism at the University of California Berkeley, so he has knowledge of most all current trends in photography today. Ken posted about this exhibition call on social media and I took the opportunity to get my work in front of his eyes. I didn’t know about Art Intersection before the call but in researching it some it looks like Alan Fitzgerald, the Executive Director, is overseeing a good space with a great photography community. I’m glad to have discovered Art Intersection.

With Ken selecting these images for the exhibition it gives me some validation for my pandemic portfolio which makes me very happy. I think mu pandemic era photographs will become an important documentation of what occurred during the pandemic, especially here in Southern California.

Art Intersection Gallery

207 N. Gilbert Road, Suite 201 - Gilbert, Arizona, 85234 480-361-1118

Gallery Hours: Wednesday - Saturday 10 AM to 6 PM

 
In Street Photography, Photography Exhibitions, Photography, Photographer, Galleries Tags Ken Light, Art Intersection Gallery, Gilbert, Arizona, Picturing Resistance, William Karl Valentine, Documentary Photography, Photography, Photographer, Protests, California
Comment
View fullsize Mark Cáceres’s "Brass Band"
Mark Cáceres’s "Brass Band"
View fullsize Mark Cáceres’s "Woman with Braided Hair"
Mark Cáceres’s "Woman with Braided Hair"

Mark Cáceres - Atlanta based Photographer

July 12, 2023

I have had the opportunity to exhibit my photographs with Mark Cáceres’s photographs three times over the last two years.  I respect Mark and his work.  Mark is based in Atlanta, and I had the chance to meet him, and some other Atlanta Photography Group members, last October when I went to Atlanta for an opening.  The Photography scene in Atlanta is really good, and Mark is a big part of that.

When I was preparing my blog post about getting a photograph into South x Southeast’s Small Works Exhibition I referenced the “Slow Exposures” Photography Festival which will be happening concurrently at a nearby gallery.  Their website showcased last years participants and I saw that Mark’s Photograph “Brass Band” won the People’s Choice Award and that his “Woman with Braided hair”, which I think is outstanding, earned an Honorable Mention.

Being reminded of Mark’s work again, I decided to do a quick blog post to showcase it.  His Instagram has the best examples of recent work, he just posted more images from his trip to Italy today, while his website showcases the breadth of his work.  Mark is a photographer worth following, he is capturing some great images and he does amazing things with available light.

In Artist, Photographer, Galleries Tags Mark Cáceres, Atlanta Photography Group, Atlanta, South x Southeast, Slow Exposures Photography Festival, American South, Photographer
Comment
web+ca+dsc09840+11212019+.jpg

HEARTLAND - An American Road Trip in 1963 Thomas Hoepker

November 21, 2019
web ca dsc09841 11212019 .jpg

I just picked up a copy of Thomas Hoepker’s book Heartland by Peperoni Books (Second Edition 2013). Came across it on line, saw Magnum was offering autographed copies, and it caught my attention. I was first drawn to the documentary aspect of the book. Thought it would be interesting to compare it to Robert Frank’s work a few years earlier. I was also wanted explore the book because the images were all from 1963, the year I was born. Had an idea about some self exploration by reflecting back to the era I came from compared to where I am at today. Not to be overly deep, more inquisitive.

Overall I like the book and am very happy I have added it to the library.

I like the size, printing, and feel of the book. The crafting of it is appropriate, has a clean look. My biggest knock is some of the image titles are redundant (It is one of the things I pick up on, part of why most my images are untitled). For example: “Woman at a Jukebox in South Dakota”, I can clearly see it is a woman by a Jukebox, I don’t need that information. Love knowing the photograph is from South Dakota, would love to know the city, the bar, or any other facts the image doesn’t tell me. I assume this is the title Hoepker gave the image, and for a reference title its fine, I just don’t see the need to use it in the book. Most folks probably will not notice, its just one of the things I am particular about, I love as much information as I can get and I don’t like redundancy . But back to what is important, this photograph is a great image. The solo man’s hat on the rack above the jukebox, the woman sitting alone, her eyes… there is a ton here in this image. The book layout is also a perfect pairing of the image opposite of the couple dancing in Arizona, takes it to a deeper level still.

web ca dsc09847 11212019 .jpg

Some of the images which really stood out to me are below. I photograph in cemeteries a lot so the photographs from LA were of immediate interest. The vertical image is from Hollywood Forever Cemetery which is an awesome place (you can find images from there in my Cemeteries Series) and the Forrest Lawn statue had been photographed by Winogrand and other greats, Hoepker was obviously chasing old tripod holes. The two images related to Kennedy’s assassination are perfect to document the year since that was by far one of the most important events of our history. The boy dressed up as a soldier resonated with me, I know the country was becoming more involved with the Vietnam War and its pretty obvious many of the toys for boys then were war based supporting that effort. Personally I remember most of my favorite toys were Hot Wheels or toys soldiers and plastic guns. I can relate to the boy in the photo on a lot of levels. The woman by the Campbell’s soup cans is just fantastic because she is in a rural America where more likely than not she is surrounded by farms with fresh and healthy food. The current state of our food supply is beyond frustrating for me and this era is pretty much where the commercialization food all started. I also recognize the parallels to Warhol and the art scene with the Campbell’s cans. This is my favorite photograph in the book. My final example is of the man in Pierre, South Dakota. I had no idea there was a Statue of Liberty replica statue in Pierre and I can’t ever remember a noteworthy photographer who had photographed in Pierre. Pierre was my Grandfather’s hometown and it has long been on my bucket list to visit. Reaffirms that every viewer brings something different with them when they look at an image that effects their response to that image.

View fullsize web ca dsc09842 11212019 .jpg
View fullsize web ca dsc09843 11212019 .jpg
View fullsize web ca dsc09844 11212019 .jpg
View fullsize web ca dsc09846 11212019 .jpg

Before buying the book I was familiar with Hoepker’s work but did not know it as well I should. Knew he is a Magnum photographer (joined in 1989 and was President of Magnum from 2003-2006) and knew his photographs of Muhammad Ali. So I did some research for this post. One of my favorite Hoepker photographs is of several couples at a make out spot across the river from the World Trade Center in the 1980’s. I have seen the image before and just think its a great document which captures the era and place so well. I found a feature on Hoepker’s color work in New York during the 1980’s on the site Viewing NYC which has the image featured. I also found a Hoepker article on KLAT which I thought was a good read. Hoepker’s main web site is on Magnum. If you decide to explore Hoepker’s work more I also also suggest viewing his photographs documenting Germany during the cold war.

Tags Thomas Hoepker, Heartland, Magnum, Photographer, Ali, Viewing NYC, KLAT, William Karl Valentine, Peperoni Books
Comment
Blog Index

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/williamkarlvalentine/


Twitter

@Valentinephotog

 

Powered by Squarespace